Saturday, February 13, 2021

La Sportiva Cyklon Review: Is it a trail runner or very light highly technical terrain boot?

 Article by John Tribbia

La Sportiva Cyklon ($160)

Introduction

Coming in at approximately 11 oz (311 grams) in a 42 EU size with a 8 mm drop, and an MSRP of $160, the Cyklon is destined for sky racers and mountain enthusiasts who gravitate toward off-road technical terrain for short to medium distances.


John: A few months ago, I wrote about and reviewed the La Sportiva Karacal. In that review I mentioned a recent interview with Jonathan Wyatt (multi-time World Mountain Running champion and La Sportiva Running Product Specialist). In it he compares the Karacal and soon to be released Cyklon.


Although the Cyklon is similar to the Karacal with design attributes built for technical terrain, Wyatt indicates the Cyklon is a completely different beast of a shoe altogether. Sportiva was looking to design a shoe that excelled in challenging terrain and in mixed climbing and running situations, La Sportiva manifested the Cyklon to provide adventure seekers the highest level of stability and security. To that end, the customizable, precise, and secure fit of the Cyklon is thanks to a sophisticated Dynamic Cage design feature that fits over the midfoot and is controlled by a BOA system. 


The one-two punch of the Cage and BOA allow on the fly micro adjustments that are adaptable to the changes in foot volume over the long haul, thus ensuring maximum comfort in long distance objectives. 


Pros:

John: precise and customizable fit, very stable and predictable, well protected, and very efficient in technical terrain. 


Cons:

John: boot like, harsh ride and transitions when running


Tester Profile

John Tribbia (5' 6", 130lbs) is a former sponsored mountain/trail runner who has run with La Sportiva, Brooks/Fleet Feet, Pearl Izumi, and Salomon. Even though he competes less frequently these days, you can still find John enjoying the daily grind of running on any surface, though his favorite terrain is 30-40% grade climbs. He has won races such as America's Uphill, Imogene Pass Run, and the US Skyrunner Vertical Kilometer Series; and he's held several FKTs on several iconic mountains in Boulder, Colorado and Salt Lake City, Utah. If you follow him on Strava, you'll notice he runs at varying paces between 5 minutes/mile to 12 minutes/mile before the break of dawn almost everyday.


Stats

Sample Weight: 11oz / 311g men's / (US9) 

Stack Height: 28mm Heel / 20mm Toe

Available  Spring 2021. $160.


First Impressions and Fit

John: The La Sportiva Cyklon is incredibly comfortable and almost boot-like given the amount of support I feel in the shoe. The BOA system is well designed and holds my heel and forefoot securely in place. The structured heel is stiffer than other shoes I have run in, but not in an uncomfortable way. The upper is comfortable on the foot with no abrasive spots, breathes well, and works well in tandem with the BOA lacing system to envelope the foot. 


Upper

John: With the combination of breathable and high abrasion resistant 4-way mesh and a multi-layer thermo adhesive side panel overlay, the upper of the Cyklon is an excellent combination of breathability and protection. The heel collar is high and constructed sock-like and stretches to envelope the foot. I find the padding and material to be very comfortable, especially for a higher cut heel. 

Image: LaSportiva.com


There’s an external heel cup that also supports the BOA system and provides structure to the upper and greatly enhances the heel hold. In fact, it is almost a boot-like feel, which is great in technical terrain where ankle rolls can be commonplace. Related, the midfoot hold is excellent. With the combination of a secure heel and midfoot, the high customizable fit in the forefoot / toe box allows for swelling and splay, which I find gives me better control on the technical terrain. 


Overall, the upper security is exceptional, especially on steep technical terrain.

The BOA system with external guides is accompanied by Spyral tongue and Dynamic Cage that yield an efficient quick one-hand lacing adjustment. The design of the lacing system wraps over the foot and pulls the upper over the forefoot like a blanket (as opposed to pulling the two sides together) and in my opinion provides a much more secure fit than any other BOA system I have tried before. 

I would say, too, that the BOA is the star of this shoe as it provides an on the fly, easily adjustable, lacing system that conveniently and efficiently supports my foot really well. Minor adjustments, on the fly and in cold weather, are extremely easy!



Midsole

John: the midsole of the Cyklon is a compression molded EVA with two co-molded medial and lateral TPU stabilizing inserts to provide stability and protect your feet from sharp and uneven rocky paths. Like many of the La Sportiva models I have run in, including recent tests  of the Karacal (RTR Review) and Jackal (RTR Review), I didn’t find the cushion to be highly conducive to running fast and nimble, nor did I find the sensation underfoot to be plush, responsive, or bouncy. All of this said the midsole feels exceptionally stable upon impact and there is some cushion thanks to the Ortholite insoles and 7mm lugs on the outsole.


Outsole

John: The FriXion XF 2.0 mudguard outsole with 7mm lugs provides great traction and security in all types of terrain. When running / hiking on rocky trail, mud, ice, gravel pack trail, snow, and off camber grassy slopes, I felt very secure and was able to be aggressive in almost any terrain. The 7mm lugs offer exceptional traction, foot protection on rocky terrain, and cushion on hard terrain. They attach well to a variety of surfaces in both warm and cold temperatures. The TPU toe guard is protective and I had no uncomfortable issues with my foot in the shoe.


Ride

John T:  I wouldn’t say the Cyklon has a particularly plush, smooth, or an upbeat and lively ride, but I found it to be protective and predictable. At 11 oz, the Cyklon is comparably lightweight for the type of terrain it is intended for and I really enjoyed how it performed on steep technical terrain. Moreover, they excel at fast paced hiking / speed walking when pushed and are very predictable and stable in technical terrain. 

The structured heel helps keep wobbliness and ankle rolls at bay. 


Conclusions and Recommendations

John: La Sportiva’s Cyklon is in a category of its own. If you are looking to add a shoe that is ideal when moving efficiently through technical mountain terrain over medium to long distances with a crossover feel between a  boot and a trail runner, the Cyklon is a top choice. The shoe is light, comfortable, and supportive. It offers the option via the BOA of a precise and dialed-in fit. It was secure, predictable, and stable when running across varied terrain, and can withstand long days in the mountains. I envision using this shoe in Sky Race type events where the terrain is ankle bending or even longer fast packing and thru-hike adventures where foot support is a necessity.

John’s Score: 9.1/10 

Ride: 9 (not ideal for fast paced running, but at its best in high alpine technical terrain)

Fit: 9 (BOA system is amazing)

Value: 8 ($160 is not bad for the shoe and its purpose, but not great either)

Style: 9  

Traction: 10 (best in class)

Rock Protection: 9.5 (toe protection, firm cushioning, outsole and durable upper)


Comparisons

Index to all RTR reviews: HERE

Salomon SpeedCross 5 (RTR Review)

John: The SpeedCross 5 is lighter, faster, with less protection. I think the SpeedCross does well in most terrain, but lacks an edge compared to the Cyklon in rocky, super technical, and uneven terrain. The Cyklon is well suited for technical trail and off-trail sections where superior traction and protection are mandatory.


Adidas Terrex Agravic Tech Pro (RTR Review)

John: I found these shoes to be very different from each other, despite sharing BOA lacing systems and general use cases. The BOA system on the Cyklon wraps over the foot while on the Terrex it pulls the two sides of the upper together. I personally prefer the Cyklon’s design and found it to be more secure. The Terrex has a water resistant overlay that zips up above the ankle and the Cyklon has a sock-like heel upper that prevents debris from getting in the shoe. The Terrex is quite a bit heavier (by 3 oz / 85g or sot) and yet it has a more lively ride from its Boost midsole and geometry. On the other hand the Cyklon is more structured and efficient through steep technical terrain. The price for Terrex is $200 compared to $160 for the Cyklon


La Sportiva Akasha (RTR Review)

John: Both the Akasha and Cyklon weigh around 11 oz, but their use cases diverge. The Akasha has slightly less drop and upper protection, while having more cushion and agility, which translates to a better longer / ultra distance shoe for rolling terrain. On the other hand the Cyklon comes with deeper lugs, a 2mm greater heel-to-toe drop, and greater overall protection and security, which makes it best for steeper and more technical terrain.



3 comments:

Kyle said...

Please let us know how this compares to the mutant!

John Tribbia said...

Hey Kyle! Thanks for your inquiry. I don't have a ton of hours in the Mutant, but I can give you a few basic comparisons I noticed. The two differ in upper protection and fit/security. The Cyklon feels more built up and ready for a trekking adventure (though it is still runnable), which was most noticeable in the secure and well protected heel fit. Moreover the BOA lacing allows for precision in the overall fit too. Both are great in technical situations. TL;DR I would use the Cyklons for a longer, slower outing up 14er/13er terrain and I would use the Mutants for more runnable options like an approach and scramble up Boulder's Flatirons or Salt Lake City's Olympus Slabs.

Let me know if you have any other questions. Thanks again!

-John

Kyle said...

Awesome, thanks John!