Friday, January 20, 2017

In Depth Comparative Review: Skechers Performance GOmeb Razor & GOrun 5

Review by Peter Stuart and Patrick Caron

Editor's Note:

Skechers Performance has released the new GOmeb Razor and the updated GOrun 5

Both models share:

  • nearly identical weights of around 7.5 oz/213 g in a men's 9 
  • identical midsole stack of 14 mm/18 mm and total stack height of 22mm/30mm
  • GOKnit uppers
  • 5GEN midsole
  • same outsole
Left: GOrun 5                                              Right: GOmeb Razor
So what are the technical differences between these two shoes?
  • the GOrun 5 upper uses a circular knit GOKnit for a sock like fit while the GOmeb Razor uses a more supportive flat knit GOKnit material to get that secure fit Meb prefers.
  • the lacing system is different with fewer lace loops on the GOrun 5 for a more slipper like fit
  • the Razor heel counter is wider at the foot and achilles levels and is firmer than the GOrun 5
  • the shared 5GEN midsole material is firmer in the Razor

I briefly ran in both shoes and found the Razor firmer with a looser heel hold. The GOrun 5 had a less supportive yet very comfortable foot hold and seemed a touch pointier both likely due to the less structured circular knit upper. 

Left: GOrun 5                                              Right: GOmeb Razor
Let's hear what Peter and Patrick thought. Peter is a sub 3 hour marathon Masters runner.  Patrick is a 19 year old ultra runner who had the 9th fastest US 100 mile time of 2016, 14:51. He was also the 1st finisher under 20 years of age at the 2016 Boston Marathon(2:46)  along with winning several other 2016 ultras wins.

FIRST IMPRESSIONS
Skechers GOrun 5. PC: www.jonfrederickphotography.com

GOmeb Razor Razor

Peter:
Aha, this is the goldilocks shoe from Skechers!!! First run in this shoe suggests that it’s exactly what the earlier shoes suggested was possible. I liked the GoRun series, but found it to be slightly too little shoe—sometimes a little too soft and too flexible. The GoSpeed was just a little too stiff for my preferences (I know, I know they work great for Meb and when I can run 4:40’s I may like them better!). The Razor completely nails the space between those two shoes. The Skechers Razor is a super light (7.7 oz for a men’s 9) daily trainer and racer with a heel height of 18mm and forefoot of 14mm. It’s firmer than the GoRun series without feeling at all stiff. I’ve run easy, run long and run fast in them and it has been a joy across all runs.

Patrick:
These shoes scream speed right out of the box and their flashy, patterned design is certain to turn some heads. As someone who sticks to low-drop, lightweight shoes, the GOmeb Razor fits right in amongst the rest of my trainers, offering a natural and versatile ride.

GORun 5
Peter:
A really nice update to the GORun series. The upper is slipper-like, super comfortable and fits well. They weigh 7.5 oz (men’s 9) and have the same 18mm/14mm stack height of the Razor. They are a softer ride than the Razor, and are really fun to run in.
Patrick:
The similarity in the look and specs of the GOrun 5 to the GOmeb Razor is wild, considering how vastly different they feel on the foot and on the run. A snugger, narrower upper makes the GOrun 5 seem more like a racer, although it’s softer midsole would beg to differ. This plush, cushioned feel makes it perfect for longer races, protecting runners from wear and tear while still providing some rebound.

UPPER & FIT

Left: GOrun 5                                              Right: GOmeb Razor
Peter:
Both the Razor and the GoRun5 have GoKnit™ uppers. They both fit true to size and have soft, supportive uppers. The Razor has 6 eyelets (with another to use for lace-lock) while the GoRun5 has only 3 eyelets (also with an extra eyelet up top). This is the major difference in the uppers of these two shoes and has a real effect on the feeling of the shoes. While the GoRun5 feels like a slipper and lightly holds the foot, the Razor is a more traditional lacing and more solidly holds the foot in place. This makes for a more standard running shoe feel, and is a very secure fit.
Both shoes seem to have varying densities of knit for breathability and hold. The GoRun5 has a “Quick Fit” feature on the back, which is essentially a pull-tab on the back of the heel to yank the shoe on or off. This is a nice feature for triathlon. The heel counter on the Razor seems a bit more substantial than the counter on the GoRun5.
Skechers GOmeb Razor. PC: www.jonfrederickphotography.com
Patrick:
Skechers GOrun 5  PC: www.jonfrederickphotography.com
GOmeb Razor
The step in feel of this shoe is great. Featuring a GO KNIT upper, the GOmeb Razor provides a secure yet freeing feel around the foot. The upper material is a bit thicker than the material used on the GOrun 5, likely improving the durability of the shoe. The flexible upper combined with the more natural foot shape (no pointy toe box here!) has meant zero foot issues for me, no matter what the distance (and as a fan of sockless running for practically all my runs, this is definitely something I’m happy about). The heel counter has a “barely there” feel and the width of the heel is about average. The reflective detailing on the upper is a nice touch, making them highly visible in low-light conditions.

Left: GOmeb Razor                                       Right: Razor GOrun 5

GOrun 5 
The GOrun 5 features a GO KNIT upper similar to the GOmeb Razor, but is made of a thinner and softer material. There is also an integrated inner support strap-on either side of the second eyelet. This, combined with a narrower last and lower forefoot volume, gives the shoe a dialed-down fit, like that of a racing flat. The laces do not have as many eyelets as the GOmeb Razor (or your typical shoe), which means they have to be pulled a bit tighter to feel secure. The GOrun 5 also features a narrower heel, which holds the foot nicely. A quick-fit pull tag is also attached allowing for quick on and offs. Sockless runs in the GOrun 5 left me with no worries!


MIDSOLE & OUTSOLE
Peter:
Both the Razor and the GORun 5 feature 5GEN® cushioning for the midsole with a layer of blown rubber covering areas of the mid-foot, forefoot and heel. There’s not a ton of blown rubber underneath, but grip and ride are great. What’s really interesting is that with both shoes featuring the same material, with seemingly the same layout of blown rubber, they ride quite differently.

Both shoes have some exposed midsole, and I’m starting to see a little bit of wear around the edges (where there’s no blown rubber). I’m not sure it will be problematic, but I’m keeping an eye on it.
Skechers GOmeb Razor PC: www.jonfrederickphotography.com
Patrick:
GOmeb Razor - The midsole of the GOmeb Razor is made of Skechers 5Gen material. While running they have a firm feel with a bit of pop, but still offer plenty of cushion for longer runs. The GOmeb Razor also features a full ground contact outsole (with a diagonal/diamond pattern), with some additional durable rubber in the heel and forefoot. This really impressed me, as it led to a very smooth ride. The GOmeb Razor is designed to be a more cushioned version of the GOmeb Speed, but still offers plenty of energy return for faster efforts.

GOrun 5 - Just like the GOmeb Razor, the midsole of the GOrun 5 utilizes Skechers 5Gen material, although it’s durometer (hardness) is a few notches down. The outsole has the same full ground contact outsole (with a diagonal/diamond pattern), designed to provide grip on a variety of surfaces.

RIDE
Peter:
This is where the Razor and the GoRun5 are clearly two different shoes:
GOmeb Razor : The Razor is firmer, has more support through the arch and a ‘snappier’ feel. The relative firmness allows for speedier turnover when you step on the gas. The Razor’s firmness doesn’t prevent it from being well-cushioned and protective of the forefoot. It’s a nice middle-ground and holds up well over long miles.

GORun 5: The GoRun5 is a fairly soft shoe. It ALMOST feels like it will bottom out, while never really doing so. On most of my runs so far in the GoRun5, the first mile has felt a little too soft, and all subsequent miles have felt just right. It’s a nice long-run shoe and goes fast if you need it to, but I do feel that you lose a little bit of energy return from the road due to the softness of the forefoot.
Skechers GOmeb Razor PC: www.jonfrederickphotography.com
Patrick:
GOmeb Razor - The GOmeb Razor has a very unique (in a good way!) ride. The snappiness was very apparent, and I found myself looking to pick up the pace while wearing this shoe. The versatility of the shoe is pretty surprising, as I’ve taken this pair with me on a wide range of runs and paces over the past couple weeks. Whether you’re racing or headed out for a casual jaunt around the neighborhood this shoe will live up to your expectations every time.

GOrun 5 - The GOmeb Razor and GOrun 5 both come in at around 7.5 ounces, and both have an airy, “barely there” feel on your feet. The ride of the GOrun 5 differs from that of the GOmeb Razor in that it has a softer underfoot, with a bit of bounce to it. The GOrun 5 also features a full ground contact outsole like the GOmeb Razor, making the transition from landing to toeing off very fluid. Similar to the GOmeb Razor, the GOrun 5 can be used for a variety of runs, but based off of the fit of the upper, I personally think the GOrun 5 is better suited for race day or a hard, uptempo workout.

RECCOMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
Skechers GOrun 5  PC: www.jonfrederickphotography.com
Peter:
Both of these shoes feel like a significant step forward for Skechers. It’s interesting to try to figure out how two shoes with nearly identical specs feel so different on the road. Ultimately, the Razor feels like a daily trainer/distance racer while I might use the GoRun as more of a recovery and daily trainer. I guess it depends more on the mood I’m in. They’re both terrific shoes. Skechers has dropped the M-Strike and gone to a more typical running shoe tread that’s nearly full-contact.

The Razor is one of my favorite shoes at the moment. It’s comfortable, versatile, inexpensive and I can see it being a great pick for runners of all speeds and strengths. While it may be a “training shoe” for Meb, I think it’s probably a good distance racer for most of us mortals.  If the Razor didn’t exist I might be a little more excited about the GoRun5. If I had to pick one of them, I’d pick the Razor, but I’m very happy to have both.
Skechers GOmeb Razor PC: www.jonfrederickphotography.com
Patrick:
GOmeb Razor - Impressive to say the least! With a thumbs up in the looks department and a performance to match, this shoe confirms my belief that Skechers deserves a place right next to other top running shoe brands. I am excited to see what is to come from the brand in 2017 and beyond. 

GOrun 5 - A great shoe overall, and an improvement from past iterations of this model, the GOrun 5 is a soft yet fast performance trainer, with a low to the ground, bouncy ride. After testing both models over a couple weeks of high mileage training, I’d also like to point out the durability of these shoes is pretty spectacular. With little noticeable wear on the sole after 50 miles, these shoes have plenty of pop left, feeling practically the same as when they were first taken out of their boxes.

COMPARISONS
Peter:
GOmeb Razor and GoRun5 vs. Nike Zoom Elite 9
These are easily my 3 favorite shoes at the moment. The Nike sits in-between the GoRun and the Razor in terms of firmness and flexibility. I’d be hard pressed to choose between them, so I’ll just highly recommend all 3.
GOmeb Razor and GORun vs. Saucony Freedom ISO
The Skechers shoes are more forgiving in the forefoot and the GoRun is equally slipper-ish as the Freedom. I’d go GoRun 5 over the Freedom.
GOmeb Razor vs. Nike Pegasus 33.
The Razor is lighter and has a slightly more fluid ride than the Pegasus.
GOmeb Razor vs. GOmeb 3
The GoMeb 3 was too stiff for me. I prefer the Razor.

Patrick:
GOmeb Razor / GOrun 5 vs. Altra One 2.5 - My go-to shoe, the Altra One 2.5, has a similar soft feel to that of the GOrun 5, but a more open and natural-shaped forefoot like that of the Razor. The Altra One 2.5 is the lightest of the three shoes, and is zero-drop as opposed to 4mm drop like the Skechers.
GOmeb Razor / GOrun 5 vs. Saucony Kinvara 7 - The Saucony Kinvara 7 falls into the same ballpark as the GOmeb Razor and GOrun 5, but more so the GOmeb Razor. All three of these shoes are 4mm drop, and designed to be lightweight, versatile trainers/racers. The Kinvara 7 is the firmest of the three shoes, but the GOmeb Razor feels like it has more pop. The Skechers are a little more flexible and feature more comfortable and smooth engineered-mesh uppers.

Skechers GOmeb Razor / GOrun 5 vs. Hoka Tracer - The Hoka Tracer is a lighter, much firmer shoe than both the GOmeb Razor and the GOrun 5, but all three feature a 4mm drop, and are great for both speed workouts and long distance races. The GOrun 5 and Tracer have a similar, snug fitting upper to one another, and the GOmeb Razor has a quick, responsive feel like that of the Tracer.

SCORE
Skechers GOmeb Razor
Peter Score 9.5 out of 10
-.25 for potential wear of the exposed midsole.
-.25 for looks. Skechers are getting better, but I still feel they lag in the design department.
Patrick's Score - 9.75 out 10
- .25 for traction (granted, it is winter in New England and these aren’t designed for some of the trails I take them on)

Skechers GORun5
Peter's Score 9.0 out of 10
-.5 soft ride on the verge of bottoming out
-.5 somewhat loose fit on the foot
Patrick's Score 9.00 out of 10
- .25 for the laces (having less eyelets might simplify the shoe, but it felt odd lacing)
- .25 for the softness of the midsole (just a tad too much squish)
- .25 for the heel tab (I’m sure it’s useful for some, but I found it to be an unnecessary addition)

- .25 for traction (same sole as GOmeb Razor)

See Derek Li's First Impressions RTR Review of the GOrun 5 here
See our The Running Event preview with information on the GOmeb Speed 4 and video comparison of the Razor and Run 5 here 
The GOrun 5 and GOmeb Razor were provided at no cost. The opinions herein entirely the authors'.

Like & Follow Road Trail Run
Facebook:roadtrailrun.com  Twitter: @roadtrailrun Instagram:roadtrailrun
Click Here our Latest Running Shoe and Gear Reviews
Shop Skechers Performance including the GOmeb Razor and GOrun 5 
at Running Warehouse!


Men's here

Women's here

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

How would you guys compare these to the LunarTempo? Both these look fantastic and maybe my first foray into Skechers.

Peter Stuart said...

Actually the Go Run 5 is pretty similar to the Lunar Tempo in flexibility and feel. I'd say the firmness of the forefoot of the lunar tempo is slightly firmer than the GoRUn 5 and slightly less firm than the Razor.

Anonymous said...

The midsole of these just reminds me of Lunarlon by appearance so makes sense. With the outsole on these, they might make a great light duty trail shoe as that's mainly what I use the LT for currently.

Anonymous said...

Peter...did you go same size in the Razor and peg 33? Peg 33 is pretty stable for a neutral shoe..are the Razor fairly stable. Other reports seem to say so because of the straighter last and wide sole...did you find that that case? How about compared to ride over the Altra torin? Thanks

Peter Stuart said...

Yes, same size in Razor and Peg. The Razor feels pretty stable to me--lighter than the peg, but still holds the foot well under the arch. compared to the Torin, i feel that the Razor is a little smoother in transition, a little snappier.

Bruce said...

can you compare these, esp. the razor, to the zoom streak 6? notably more cushioned? i'm loving the zoom streak!

thanks.

Ryan Schneider said...

I tried the GoRun 5 and while I enjoyed the lightweight and soft ride, I felt like it had no "spring" to it. Just felt like I was bottoming out with every stride. Switched to the "new" New Balance Fresh Foam Boracay v3 and while it's about 2 oz heavier, it has the soft ride plus the spring I was looking for.

Anonymous said...

Hi, what shoe do you recommend for fast series? Razor the GR5? Between these and the Newton Distance III which would advise? Weight 61 kg, thanks and I love your reviews

Patrick said...

Ryan, I would definitely give the Gomeb Razor a shot, it has the spring and lightness you'd be looking for!

Patrick said...

Anonymous, to answer your question "what shoe do you recommend for fast series?" I would think you would prefer the GOmeb Razor, since although both shoes have practically the same specs (weight, heel-to-toe drop, etc), the GOmeb Razor has a more responsive ride, which is great for racing or uptempo runs. The GOrun 5 has a softer, more plush feel under the foot. The GOmeb Razor is also probably more similar to the Distance III than the GOrun 5 is.

Anonymous said...

I get confused by the forefoot descriptions of both shoes. The Go run 5 has more stretch in the upper compared to the Razor. In this review it is stated that the Go Run has a smaller last, but I don't see this confirmed elsewhere. My question is simple: I have quite wide feet and I wonder wich shoe will accomodate my feet the best. I have the GR 4 - 2016 and use this one without the provided insole.

Patrick said...

Anonymous, I confirmed with Skechers Performance the fact that the GOrun 5 has a narrower last than the GOmeb Razor. he GOmeb Razor would definitely be better for you if you have wider feet.

Anonymous said...

Thank you for asking!

Anonymous said...

My size with the kinvara is 9.5 can you estimate the size for the gorun 5..