Up next in 10
Nike Zoom Fly 6 vs ASICS Magic Speed 4 Comparison Review: almost the same stats different rides
3K views
Nov 17, 2024
in the video I compare the brand new Nike Zoom Fly 6 to ASICS Magic Speed 4. 00:00 Intro and Details. From the run: 05:08 Fit and Ride. 08:54 Conclusions. Written Reviews Nike Zoom Fly 6: https://www.roadtrailrun.com/2024/11/test-des-nike-zoom-fly-6-avec-6.html ASICS Magic Speed 4: https://www.roadtrailrun.com/2024/05/asics-magic-speed-4-speeding-up-to.html Samples were provided at no charge for testing purposes with no additional compensation. The opinions herein are entirely the author's 100's of Run Shoes and Gear Multi Tester written reviews at www.roadtrailrun.com SHOP Running Warehouse at the links below for the widest selection of run shoes and gear anywhere and help support our channel! USA https://tinyurl.com/RWRTRUS EUROPE https://tinyurl.com/RWRTREU EU Only: Use RTR code RTR5ALL for 5% off all products, even sale products AUSTRALIA: https://www.runningwarehouse.com.au/?from=rtr EUROPE SHOP Top4Running https://tinyurl.com/bh9t3hpm
View Video Transcript
0:00
in the video we're going to compare
0:01
Nike's Zoom fly 6 to A6 magic speed 4
0:05
both are
0:06
$170 the zfly gets a big update long
0:11
overdue whereas the magic speed 4 gains
0:14
quite a bit more stack heite and is
0:16
really a different shoe than its
0:18
predecessor they both have more Comfort
0:20
oriented performance uppers that fit
0:22
quite similarly and are true to size and
0:25
they're both priced the same at
0:27
$170 let's get into the details
0:30
hello everybody Sam from Road run today
0:32
we're going to take a look at the A6
0:34
magic speed for $170 and the brand new
0:38
Nike Zoom fly 6 also
0:42
$170 and the similarities don't end
0:44
there as our new Nike has a combination
0:48
of zoomx super critical foam and um sr2
0:53
more evish below with a full fly plate
0:57
carbon plate while our as
1:00
has uh flight foam uh turbo uh their
1:04
super critical foam and flight foam
1:07
blast also with a full uh uh carbon
1:11
plate and a cavity that's quite similar
1:14
so their stock Heights are within a
1:16
millimeter and a half of each other with
1:19
the magic speed at uh uh 43 1/2 mm heel
1:26
and 35 1/2 4T 8 mm drop the Nike at uh
1:33
4234 uh but what we're going to find out
1:35
when I do the ab run which I'm going to
1:37
take you on one on each foot is uh
1:40
there's quite a difference in ride
1:42
between these two and um it's quite
1:45
noticeable really so I'll give you a bit
1:47
of a a sneak peek uh firmer 4 foot more
1:52
of a rolling motion a bit more
1:56
aggressive bouncier and softer more of a
1:59
vertical kind of motion and a bit more
2:02
stable at the heel for the uh for the
2:05
as6 as you can see we have sort of a
2:08
canal lever versus a squared off heel
2:11
and then uh let's talk a bit about the
2:13
upper I'm going to get into that on the
2:14
Run uh very similar in fit this is what
2:17
I call a performance Comfort kind of
2:20
upper uh soft dish mesh the Nikes is a
2:23
bit a bit uh thinner I think but very
2:26
quite similar uh we'll get into it but
2:29
uh look at this uh the Nike unlike the
2:32
Pegasus plus and so I just wanted to
2:35
show you you can see our zoomfly 6 has a
2:39
much more rounded front of the toe box
2:43
um it's a more kind of tubular kind of
2:46
fit than the uh Pegasus plus I think the
2:49
Pegasus plus may have a bit more room
2:52
sort of Right Where the laces uh end um
2:56
but there's no uh strap over the top of
2:58
the zoom fly the webbing strap here
3:01
sometimes can bother especially when
3:03
they're new but you can see there's
3:06
definitely an evolution in the fit here
3:09
uh for Nike with a more rounded I would
3:11
call more round uh modern toe box with
3:15
uh more toe box room the hold is very
3:17
similar in terms of the front just a
3:20
little bit different uh heel holds Good
3:22
a bit more gentle I think than the
3:25
Pegasus plus here with our um Zoom fly 6
3:29
of bit more comfortable I think it's
3:31
really an evolution in kind of the Nike
3:34
fit we're seeing here now has a more
3:37
rounded shape the A6 is a touch pointier
3:41
uh but equally as comfortable uh they're
3:44
both true to size uh for me at 8 and a
3:46
half and I think the Nikes is has a bit
3:50
more volume uh than the as6 in terms of
3:53
their weights uh the A6 even with its 1
3:57
1/2 mm more stack height comes in at uh
4:01
8.13 o 230 G in my us
4:05
8.5 whereas our Nike not much more but
4:08
8.5 Oz uh 241 G in my us 8.5 where the
4:15
difference might come from I don't think
4:17
it's the upper maybe this higher collar
4:19
adds a teeny bit but they're they're
4:21
very similar they have carbon they have
4:23
a super critical and non-s super
4:25
critical foam it may come from the outs
4:28
soole rubber is the heaviest component
4:31
and as you can see the Nike has more
4:35
outsole depth with its waffled kind of
4:37
lugs whereas the A6 is a flatter profile
4:41
the A6 grip is always always really good
4:44
grips really well and the Nike lugs are
4:46
appreciated when you get a bit kind of
4:49
off the smooth or maybe in a bit of snow
4:52
so I've I'm taking them take I'm going
4:54
to take them out or I have taken them
4:56
out on a uh a Ab run where when I'm I
4:59
give you a feel for the real differences
5:02
between these two on the Run go out on
5:04
our run on the New Hampshire Coast now
5:07
okay let's talk about the relative fit
5:09
of these two uppers so the um the
5:13
zoomfly 6 H has a bit more volume
5:16
there's no question about it and that
5:18
rounded toe a bit more rounded toe box
5:21
and a bit more uh height however they
5:25
fit very very similarly both are kind of
5:27
comfort oriented per dment
5:31
uppers uh the fit is true to size I have
5:34
a narrower medium foot and I think the
5:38
uh A6 fit is a bit more kind of dialed
5:41
in than the Nike although uh both are
5:44
really good lace up on both are similar
5:48
and excellent heel hold a little bit of
5:51
an edge I think to the A6 um although I
5:54
think the Nikes is just a touch more
5:57
comfortable so I'm going to keep going
6:00
and give you some Impressions
6:03
comparative so let's talk about the ride
6:05
as we approach our freshly painted Town
6:08
Barn isn't it cool so the A6 has a
6:13
softer ride no question about it um that
6:16
may be due to the fact that has 1 and 1
6:19
12 mm more sack height but a thinner out
6:24
soole so maybe there's just maybe 2 or 3
6:27
mm more foam whereas the night
6:31
has a a snappier ride overall
6:35
combination of the
6:36
flexible
6:38
plate and uh the outsole providing
6:42
response has has me turning over quicker
6:46
at the front whereas with the
6:49
A6 it's more of a bounce off the
6:52
front uh terms of
6:57
training suitabilities
6:59
definitely both are uptempo both are
7:02
carbon
7:03
plated the uh as6 I think is a bit more
7:09
forgiving on the legs to slower
7:12
Paces whereas the Nike really likes to
7:17
turn over near race kind of feel it's
7:21
also noisier you can hear the plate so
7:25
the plate I think might be located lower
7:29
down so most of the boats are out of the
7:32
water few more thoughts as we run along
7:35
here by Ry Harbor where you've
7:40
got more bounce in the as6 more and
7:44
quicker response in the
7:46
Nike
7:48
so either is excellent for uptempo
7:53
training but I'd say the as6 is a little
7:57
more training friendly
8:00
whereas the Nike for sure especially if
8:03
you want some
8:04
Flex is a better choice as a
8:09
racer for those who don't want to go all
8:12
the way to Vaper fly or Alpha so I think
8:16
the A6 is a teeny touch more stable even
8:20
though its heel is 5 mm narrow than the
8:24
Nike that may be even though I said the
8:27
foam was soft
8:29
it feels more stable the foam in the as6
8:34
or the layout of Foams and I think now
8:38
that I'm moving along the heel counter
8:41
is a bit more secure and that'll lead to
8:43
to stability but no real issues with the
8:47
Nike just the
8:50
difference okay a few conclusions uh I
8:54
think they're both very very similar as
8:56
I said in stack height and weight and in
8:59
construction with carbon plates and dual
9:02
Foams a super critical and a uh more Eva
9:06
like um I think the magic speed uh 4
9:10
because it's a little softer a little
9:13
more cushioned and I think that even
9:15
though it's only a millimeter and a half
9:18
higher than the Nike I think that comes
9:21
from the difference in the outsole
9:23
Heights as well so instead of just a
9:25
millimeter and a half we may have uh 2
9:29
and a half or 3 mm more compared to the
9:32
as6 and I think that makes a bit of a
9:36
difference um so I I as a training
9:39
uptempo training shoe and I think for I
9:41
would run it for a marathon I'd run
9:43
something else for half I'm going to
9:45
pick the uh the A6 magic speed 4 8.13 o
9:50
in my us 8.5 now the Nike is more uh I
9:55
would call a fast workout shoe uh up
9:59
Tempo feel it does have that extra
10:02
traction I think even though as6 grip is
10:04
always really good so it it'll probably
10:07
handle some rough stuff a bit better it
10:09
has a more relaxed fit a somewhat more
10:13
relaxed fit I tend to prefer a bit more
10:15
dialed in both of them have super soft
10:18
friendly uppers as you can see about the
10:21
same thickness the Nikes maybe a touch
10:23
thinner both of them lace up just
10:26
beautifully um the A6 uh even even
10:29
though its heel collar
10:32
is uh lower has a bit better hold than
10:35
the Nike not sure why in terms of that
10:38
stability now that I've got them off at
10:40
the rear you'll notice how the A6 is
10:42
more squared off whereas we have a more
10:44
candal levered approach here to the Nike
10:47
which uh I think makes it just a teeny
10:50
touch less stable at the rear than the a
10:52
press the heel counters okay it's
10:54
moderately rigid and over here about the
10:57
same but the hold is a little bit better
11:00
uh that may be due to the it being a
11:03
little narrower opening um and having a
11:06
touch less padding so it it's a bit
11:08
snugger through here uh in terms of the
11:12
um in terms of the toe boxes everybody
11:15
likes to hear about the toe boxes quite
11:18
similar uh true to size for me the Nike
11:21
is a bit more rounded um if a teeny bit
11:25
shorter but I wouldn't worry it's true
11:26
to size if you have a somewhat wider
11:29
foot this the Nike might do you
11:32
better um what would I use the Nike for
11:35
well I would use it for uptempo workouts
11:39
I would race in it as well especially if
11:41
it was a somewhat shorter race uh it's a
11:44
great alternative to the full carbon
11:47
what I even though it feels a bit
11:49
thinner than the A6 up front the cushion
11:51
and maybe the location of the plate not
11:54
sure the relative locations what I
11:56
really like here uh is some Flex as you
11:59
can see there's some Flex whereas our A6
12:03
is more a rigid rocker no flex so you've
12:07
kind of got a bounce off the front not a
12:10
problem but uh this this has a snappier
12:12
kind of quicker feel if a thinner one up
12:15
front so thank you very much for
12:18
watching uh we have full m full reviews
12:21
of both of them on road trailrun uh.com
12:24
written reviews have a great run I'm
12:27
going to keep going along the coast here
12:29
it's just beautiful today
#Athletic Apparel
#Footwear
#Sports